I was interviewed this morning by a radio station on the Isle of Man where smoking will not be banned in enclosed public places until March 30, 2008.
Anxious, perhaps, to attract some attention now, the island government has announced that it will go one stage further than the rest of the UK and ban smoking in prison as well. Not just in cells or designated smoking rooms, but outdoor areas too.
Home affairs Minister Martyn Quayle MHK commented:
"Although the Isle of Man will be among the last to prohibit smoking in public places when the ban comes in on March 30, 2008, we could be the first in Britain and possibly in Europe to have a smoke-free jail when the new prison opens at Jurby. It will provide clean air, free from the harmful effects of secondhand smoke, to staff and prisoners and will encourage prisoners – the majority of whom smoke – to break their addiction to nicotine."
The telling phrase is the hopeful boast that "we could be the first in Britain and possibly in Europe to have a smoke-free jail". It reminds me of Ireland, 2004, when politicians and media revelled in the fact that Ireland was "leading the world" with its public smoking ban. It's as if governments are having a race to see who can be first to introduce the next draconian piece of anti-smoking legislation. Think of the headlines! Think of the awards!
As it happens, I don't believe that inmates have a right to smoke in jail, any more than they have a right to drink alcohol. If you get sent to prison you have to the face the consequences, and one of the consequences is that you may not be able to smoke tobacco (although you will almost certainly be able to get your hands on plenty of illegal drugs).
Nevertheless, while smoking in prison isn't (in my view) a human or civil right, I don't believe that banning inmates from smoking is entirely sensible. Like it or not, smoking is a stress reliever for many people and there can't be many more stressful places than the UK's overcrowded jails. Allowing staff and inmates to smoke in exercise yards or designated smoking rooms or cells (with another smoker) makes perfect sense to me. But I'm not a politician.
PS. In 2004, when we launched our 'Fight For Choice' campaign, we produced a series of posters and postcards, one of which featured the image above. Little did we suspect that smoking in prison would also be on the agenda.