"A woman was thrown from a station platform on to an electrified railway line today after telling two youths to stop smoking. The female commuter suffered burns and a suspected broken collarbone, and was taken to hospital after the incident at Farningham Road station in Kent during the rush hour." (Press Association, August 6, 2008.)
I have thought hard before publishing this post because I don't want anyone to think I am trying to excuse what happened to this unfortunate woman. There is NO excuse. Nothing can justify an allegedly violent assault. The youths involved must take full responsibility for their actions - if and when the police catch them.
Nevertheless, I am intrigued that the victim has been described in some quarters as a "heroine". I don't condone people breaking the law. And I'm certainly not suggesting that we turn a blind eye to illegal or anti-social behaviour. But smoking on an open platform should be recognised for what it is - the most minor of minor offences.
People say the law's the law, and the law must be upheld, no matter what. Have those same people never, ever, exceeded the speed limit (for example)? How would they react if they were driving at 80mph on a motorway in clear conditions and another driver flashed at them to reduce their speed to the legal limit? Only a thug would respond by forcing the other driver off the road, but - if it was me - I'd be thinking, "Mind your own business, I'm not doing anyone any harm".
Unfortunately, the incident at Farningham Road station was waiting to happen. The smoking ban has legitimised even the most trivial complaint. Today, anti-smokers have all the power. They have the law on their side and, boy, are they going to use it.
Ironically, Forest was founded following a complaint by a woman who objected to someone smoking on a railway platform. Sir Christopher Foxley-Norris, a veteran World War II fighter pilot, was so annoyed to be told to put out his pipe, he decided to set up a group to defend smokers' rights.
Throughout his life Sir Christopher was a courteous smoker. If he was alive today, he would, I'm sure, be horrified by this week's incident, and he would be quick to condemn the aggressive behaviour of the youths involved.
I suspect, however, that he would also view it as the sad and inevitable consequence of a draconian restriction that leaves no room for common sense or compromise.
"A 34-year-old woman taxi driver who twice lit up in her parked car was left with a £775 bill yesterday. On the second occasion, Mary Astles hurled her cigarette out of the driver's window when she was approached by a Conwy council licensing enforcement official. The official had been shopping and felt duty bound [my italics] to report what she had witnessed as she drove past the taxi."
Is the council official a heroine too? Full story HERE.
Victoria Coren writes about the Farningham Road incident in today's Observer. See HERE. Recommended.